Creepshow: “Dead & Breakfast/Pesticide” Review

Shudder’s Creepshow followed its second season premiere last week with another pair of awesomely campy and practically gory horror stories.  This week’s episode features one hell of a cast of heavy hitters, who are well known in the horror world.  What’s even more fun than seeing these familiar faces is seeing what Creepshow puts them through…

Fear of the dark is one of the most universal and earliest fears that most people experience in their life.  There’s just something unsettling about the unknown, and in the absence of light, it reinforces that fear.  Movies like Darkness Falls and Lights Out have tackled the subject similarly, but neither were quite as atmospheric as Shudder’s latest exclusive movie, The Power.

“Dead & Breakfast”

Creepshow 4
Directed by Axelle Carolyn, Written by Michael Rousselet & Erik Sandoval

Our first story features a bed and breakfast run by a brother and sister, Sam and Pam Spinster played by C. Thomas Howell (The Outsiders, E.T., The Hitcher) and Ali Larter (Final Destination, Heroes).

Their grandmother was an alleged serial killer decades ago and this was the very house where she murdered people and hid the bodies, thus it features heavily in their tours and promotion.

Sadly, business isn’t doing well, so they invite a vlogger (Iman Benson of #BlackAF and Uncle Buck the series) who specializes in true crime videos to come stay, hoping that her large following will attract more customers.

Creepshow 5
Blending an old fashioned haunted house with internet culture did make for an interesting juxtaposition.

The vlogger (aptly named “Morgue”) is skeptical at first, but is excited to conduct an investigation, one which leads to ultimate disaster and a few insane plot twists that only Creepshow can deliver!

What really makes this story entertaining is its incredibly dark and morbid sense of humor.  One would think that having a family member be a serial killer would be a point of shame, but the Spinsters (especially Pam) are offended with Morgue doesn’t believe their grandmother was a murderer.

It’s as if this grim detail in their family lineage is their only claim to fame, and they intend to hold onto it desperately and milk it for monetary gain with their attraction.  The house itself is a lot of fun, complete with hidden chutes and pathways that were probably inspired by H.H. Holmes.

Creepshow 6
Most people watching this show would probably want to stay here at least once.

As someone who’s actually stayed in the Lizzie Borden House Bed & Breakfast (check it out if you’re interested), this episode was extra fun because it was all very reminiscent of staying there.  The only different being the Spinsters had absolutely no shame in how they recreated and promoted real life murders to the point that if you did this in real life, many would boycott it.

But that’s very much the point.  The siblings and their overall tackiness and exploitation of tragedy make us laugh and cringe simultaneously.


Creepshow 16
Directed by Greg Nicotero, Written by Frank Dietz

This story will probably be hard to watch for someone who’s afraid of bugs, but hilarious for everyone else in the room.  In what can only be an homage to “They’re Creeping Up on You!” from the original 1982 Creepshow, this story features heavily with bugs, pests, and monsters of the human kind.

Opening with an exterminator, Harland (played by Josh McDermitt of The Walking Dead), he finishes up clearing out the roaches from a therapist’s office.  The doctor herself (played by Hellraiser’s Ashley Laurence) very much looks down on him and is all too eager to get rid of him.

Creepshow 11
You know you must be creepy if the woman who dealt with Pinhead is uncomfortable with you…

Harland’s next client is far less contemptuous, but is far more eccentric and sinister in his demands.  Portrayed by the always awesome Keith David (The Thing, They Live, Tales From the Hood 2), Murdoch tells Harland he has a “pest problem” that needs dealing with.

Harland is both intrigued and then horrified upon discovering that the pests Murdoch refers to are in fact homeless people.  Against his better judgement, Harland does the job, and his own guilty conscience leads him down a trippy path of terrifying nightmares involving Murdoch and Brenda (the therapist) trying to kill him, and an array of giant bugs!

It’s in stories like this that Creepshow’s practical effects and makeup really shine in full display.  The giant pests that plague Harland like the beating heart from Edgar Allen Poe’s iconic story are grotesque and terrifying, even for people who aren’t inherently phobic of bugs.

Creepshow 15
The scary thing is paleontologists say that bugs really were this large during the age of the dinosaurs…

And on a deeper level, its themes explore the idea of who’s the real pest or the real monster?  As well as the ethics and morals of power dynamics and imbalances.  Harland is the closest thing to a “good guy”, but he still commits an atrocious act for money.

Both its themes and brilliant visuals make this one of the most memorable Creepshow stories I’ve seen thus far!

What did you think of this week’s episode?  What do you hope to see next week?  Let us know in the comments!

Creepshow is streaming exclusively on Shudder

For more reviews, rankings, lists, and other fun horror/sci-fi/fantasy content, follow Halloween Year-Round on FacebookTwitter, and YouTube!


2 thoughts on “Creepshow: “Dead & Breakfast/Pesticide” Review

  1. The first tale was solid, but the pesticide one felt rushed and a bit empty. It had so much promise! I’ve been a bit disappointed so far, but perhaps my expectations are a bit too high. Am I alone in this? Creep show watch party anyone?


    1. There’s definitely an expectation now that wasn’t there with Season 1 just because of how popular it is. Shudder used to live tweet alongs on Thursday nights when they aired on Shudder TV. But I haven’t seen anything for that recently.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s